RonRolheiser,OMI

Adult Children of Rene Descartes

A A A

For ten years, I was part of a pastoral team that conducted a program for couples preparing for marriage. My job was to give a talk on the sacrament of marriage. The scenario was always the same. We would meet on a Monday evening, about thirty couples and myself. There would be the standard introductions and then I would give a fifty-minute lecture on the theology of marriage, followed by a question period. The first question was always the same: “Why do we have to take this course?”

This was fair enough, given that of the thirty couples present only about four or five wanted to be there. The rest were there reluctantly, meaning they came only because they knew that if they didn’t take this course they could not get married in their respective churches.

So, their first question usually reflected some resentment, but it also reflected something much deeper, namely, the absence in them of any meaningful sense of the corporate body of humanity, of our interdependence in that body, and of the body of Christ.

Invariably they would justify their reluctance to be there in this way: “Why do we have to take this course? Whose business is this anyway? Why are my parents, the church, and society trying to interfere in my life? This is my life, my choice, my marriage, my honeymoon, and skin off my teeth if it doesn’t work out! This is not your business, the church’s business, my parents’ business, or society’s business! What’s your stake in my life?”

Indeed, what’s your stake in my life?

In that challenge, one hears the lonely voice of Rene Descartes (1596-1650), all those centuries ago, settling on the one thing that he could be sure of and build upon: “I think, therefore I am!” These young people, for all their sincerity and goodness, at least at this stage of their lives, were more children of Rene Descartes than of Jesus Christ.

Rene Descartes, the seventeenth century French philosopher whose ideas helped to shape both the enlightenment and many of our modern ideas, began his philosophy with the idea that the only thing we can be sure of as real is our own reality (Cogito, ergo sum). We are inside of ourselves and our own reality is massive, real, and undeniable. Everything else appears less real and is real in relation to us.

In street language this says: I am real. My life, my thoughts, my feelings, my heartaches, my headaches are real. Everything else is outside me and less real. I can relate to it, but it’s separate from me. I’m independent of it and it’s independent of me. In the end, we’re all separate from each other, isolated subjects, able at times to temporarily penetrate each other’s reality, but ultimately separate, alone, independent. What’s real is my life, my experience.

In the secularized world today, we are very much the children of that idea. Granted, it has a very positive side: Our belief in this idea is one of the reasons why we cherish and defend equality and individual rights. Western democracy and the various charters of freedoms that we so much take for granted have, to some degree, been underwritten by this idea of personal freedom.

However, Descartes’ emphasis on individuality has an underside. Among other things, this is reflected in a lack of a sense of interdependence and a false notion of freedom that was so manifest in the objections of those young people who were reluctantly taking this marriage course. In their minds, nothing is inherently owed to family, community, and humanity. Why should there be? After all we stand independent of these and we can decide on our own, to what degree we want to buy in, get involved, give ourselves over, participate in, and acquiesce to others’ expectations of us. Others have their lives and I have mine!

This is also manifest today in the attitude people (of all ages) have towards marriage: “Why do we need to get married publicly? This is just between the two of us. We have our own commitment to each other and that’s enough. Who needs a piece of paper? This is nobody’s business but ours.” 

Such an attitude would be valid, if we weren’t in our very makeup social beings, irrevocably bound to each other in life. How different from Descartes and contemporary culture is the Christian idea that we are all parts of one body, a single organism, within which one part can’t say to the other: “This is my life and it’s no business of yours?”

Two voices, two choices, two visions: Rene Descartes and Jesus Christ. One speaks of private freedom, loneliness, and individuality; the other of interdependence, community, and shared life. Like Adult Children of Alcoholics, we, Adult Children of Rene Descartes, might want to reflect more on what we carry unconsciously in our lives because of the household we grew up in.

Love and Hate

A A A

Hate isn’t the opposite of love; indifference is. Hate is love gone wrong, and how easily that happens.

D.H. Lawrence once wrote a poem he called History, which reads like this:

The listless beauty of the hour
When snow first fell on the apple trees
And the wood-ash gathered in the fire
And we faced our first miseries.

Then the sweeping sunshine of noon
When the mountains like chariot cars
Were ranked to blue battle-and you, and I
Counted our scars.

And then in a strange, grey hour
We lay mouth to mouth, with your face
Under mine like a star on the lake
And I covered the earth, and all space.

The silent, drifting hours
Of morn after morn
And night drifting up to night
Yet no pathway worn.

Your life, and mine, my love
Passing on and on, the hate
Fusing closer and closer with love
Til at length they mate.

At the beginning of every love, romantic or not, the dream for that love is connected to an ideal of purity, mutuality, and respect. Every real love begins with the idea that this time we’ll get it right, that we won’t make the mistakes we’ve made other times, that this time love will sustain its magic. And in the early stages of love, that ideal is spontaneously respected, as is the other person.

In the stage of attraction, flirtation, and infatuation, love takes its roots in the poetic imagination and enrobes itself, figuratively, in whiteness, in purity, in all that’s best inside us. Figuratively, it puts on a baptismal robe because it senses that here, finally, there will be rebirth.

There’s nothing as potentially life-giving and redeeming as falling in love. It recolors the world completely. As the great novelist, Iris Murdoch once said: “The world can change in fifteen seconds, when you fall in love.”

But the world, as we know, can also turn indifferent, dark, and angry in fifteen seconds, or fifteen years. Most of us won’t die like Romeo and Juliet, still in the grip of that bliss-producing, soul-searing, divine fever we call “falling in love”, where dying for love seems not too high a price to pay.

However, time, familiarity, differences, restlessness, old immaturities, wounded pride, a wandering eye, and simple selfishness soon enough begin to work at dispelling the magic. Where we once couldn’t get enough of each other, where we swallowed our hurts and pride and were willing like Romeo and Juliet to die for each other, we now begin to count our scars, to let things drift, and no longer search habitually for the path towards the other’s door. Hate begins to fuse with love, resentments creep in, and we slowly reclaim our singleness.

What D.H. Lawrence so brilliantly describes in this poem is how gradually and imperceptibly love can lose its purity, its divine fever, and its divine intent, even in its most intense expressions.

And what he is referring to is not that (healthy) innate structure within the very dynamics of love itself, love’s dark night of the soul, where love pressures us toward maturity beyond infatuation, illusion, and selfishness.

He is referring to a disease that can creep into a relationship when, for whatever reason, familiarity begins to breed contempt and disrespect, and the ideal that originally triggered that love is lost. Milan Kundera once said that when the idea that a love was founded on dies, then the love dies too. More accurately, it doesn’t die but it begins to fuse with hate.

Real love is always founded on the ideal of purity, mutuality, and respect. In our heart of hearts, we want what’s right, what’s best; we don’t want to stain what we love. And this implies things far beyond sex.

When we first say the words, “I love you,” and mean them, our hearts are connecting us to an ideal, a dream, a divine form, and a purity that roots itself in what’s best in us. But once we begin to compromise that ideal through any kind of disrespect or infidelity, we begin the slide down that slippery slope that Lawrence describes here and no expression of intimacy, the sexual bed included, will easily redeem the initial dream for that love. Our love then begins imperceptibly to sleep with hate, until we can no longer tell the difference. Our relationship then will produce as much resentment as delight and we will soon find ourselves becoming strangers to each other.

When we are baptized, a white dress is put on us to symbolize purity and words are spoken over us to remind us that this white garment is the outward sign of our inner dignity and our challenge is to bring that dignity unstained into eternal life. But unless we die young, this is not an easy task. Even so, what’s symbolized by our baptismal robes must be the poetic dream for every love in our lives, complete with the challenge of bringing that love home without the stain of hatred.

Don’t Try to Imagine God

A A A

If we try to imagine God, it’s easy to become an atheist. Why?

Try imagining this: We believe that one Person, God, is the sole creator of all that exists. Now, all that exists, although itself finite, is already beyond what we can imagine – billions of galaxies, trillions of planets, and billions of people stretching back through thousands of years. As well, we believe that God knows every rock, insect, animal, and plant not just on earth, but everywhere in the universe. How can we wrap our minds around that? We can’t.

And there’s the further issue of trying to picture the scope of God’s love. Today there are more than eight billion people in the world and our faith asks us to believe that God loves each one of those eight billion individually and intimately, as if he or she was the only person in the world. Moreover, through millions of years God has loved intimately every man, woman, and child on this earth, right back to our ancestors who lived in caves. How can one mind, one heart, one person do this? It’s beyond the mind.

However, and this is the point, it’s not intended to be imagined or conceptualized.

God is infinite. Infinity, by definition, is impossible to imagine. (For example, what’s the highest number it’s possible to count to?)  Infinity takes us beyond what can be conceptualized. To conceptualize something, the mind needs to start somewhere and God has no beginning. Indeed, to the extent that we do create for ourselves an imaginative picture of God, we always have something less than God, and often an idol.

And the problem is that we are forever slimming down God to fit the size of our imagination when, by its very essence and definition, God is ineffable, unable to be pictured, imagined, or captured in a concept. This is a dogmatic teaching in of all Christian Churches and in Judaism. As the prophet Isaiah says, God is holy, meaning, beyond all visualization and all conceptualization, beyond anything that can be imagined. That’s why scripture asserts that in this life “no one can see the face God and live.”

However, as Christians, we believe that Jesus came to us and in his person and teaching gave concrete expression (incarnation) to God so that we can grasp, imagine, and speak truly about certain aspects of God. To know Jesus is to know his “Father.”

 However, that’s not the same thing as capturing God in a concept. Indeed, we can “know” God, but we can’t “think” God. We can never create a “picture” of God.

Why is this important? Because whenever we do create a picture of God, we always end up with something less than God – and invariably something that works for our self-interest.

Critics of Christianity accuse us of forever creating God in our own image and likeness. There’s a lot of truth in that. That’s why the God we create for ourselves invariably likes the same people we do, hates the same people we hate, makes the same judgments we make, likes us better than other races, favors our country over others, and assures us that our religion (and our own interpretation of it) is the true way to heaven.

Whenever we capture God in a concept, we end up with a God who is no more intelligent and compassionate than we are, whose heart isn’t larger than ours, and who is unworthy of Jesus and Christianity.

For a dozen years I taught a course to seminarians entitled A Theology of God. The course looked at many things: how God is presented in scripture, the historical development of our dogmatic creeds about God, theological speculation about the nature of God, the salient critiques atheists have made about our Christian belief in God, and insights from the mystics and popular piety vis-à-vis how we might relate more affectively to God.

But throughout the course and particularly at its end, I would say this to the seminarians: Whatever else you do in your teaching, preaching, and pastoral practice, try not to make God look stupid!

In essence: try not to make God look tribal, racist, nationalistic, legalistic, denominational, sexist, rigid, petty, vengeful, angry, defensive, and anything less than unimaginable wisdom, unimaginable love, unimaginable embrace, and unimaginable forgiveness. Try not to make God just another imaginable human person with all our flaws.

I know sincere, good-hearted atheists and agnostics who don’t believe in God because when they try to imagine a Person who is creating millions of universes, billions of people, and trillion upon trillions of minerals, plants, and animals, and who is knowing and loving each element in existence intimately as if it were the only thing in existence, they can’t imagine it. Neither can we. It’s not meant to be imagined. It’s meant to be known in a cloud of unknowing, to stretch our minds and hearts beyond their natural limits and bring us to an awe that bends our knees in genuflection.